ARGC
blackArrowLeftRead more

IVF vs IUI: what's the difference and which is best for me?

Monica Karpinski avatar

Written by

Monica Karpinski

Kelda Gould avatar

Medically reviewed by

Kelda Gould

Fertility Nurse • BN in Adult Nursing

Share
Patient at ARGC London, reading about fertility treatments

Are you considering fertility treatment? We know that it’s not a decision made lightly. But remember that your clinic is there to support and guide you.

One of the things they will help you with is deciding on the type of fertility treatment best suited to your situation. IVF and IUI are two of the main options.

To help you understand what to expect, we’ve explained the difference between IVF and IUI below.

What is IVF?

IVF, or in vitro fertilisation, is one of the most common types of fertility treatment in the UK. It involves fertilising an egg in a lab (in vitro means "in the lab"), and then transferring the embryo back into the womb.

A typical IVF cycle follows these steps: taking medicines to stimulate the ovaries to grow more eggs (stimulation), collecting the eggs, fertilising the eggs, and transferring the embryo.

We take a more thorough approach than what’s standard here at ARGC. Learn more about what to expect from the IVF process.

IVF is usually suggested for people dealing with fertility issues:

  • If there’s a physical reason the egg and sperm can’t meet inside the body. For example, blocked or damaged Fallopian tubes
  • If previous IUI cycles didn’t work
  • You're dealing with moderate to severe male infertility
  • You have a reduced ovarian reserve (fewer eggs left in the ovaries)
  • If an underlying health condition, like endometriosis, is affecting your fertility
  • You have unexplained infertility. This is when we can’t pinpoint a cause for infertility
  • People who are older. Fertility naturally declines with age

You may also be recommended for IVF if your embryos need to undergo genetic testing. This may be the case if you or your partner are carrying a gene that can cause disease, or if you have a known family history of genetic disease. Your clinic will advise on what’s best.

What is IUI?

On the other hand, with IUI (intrauterine insemination), fertilisation happens inside the body. We take a sperm sample and then treat it, so we can create a smaller group of healthy sperm. We then place the healthy sperm directly into your womb around the time you ovulate.

It’s a simpler, less invasive option that doesn’t involve egg collection or embryo transfer. Sometimes stimulation medicines are used, but not always. More on that below.

We may suggest IUI as a first-line treatment for people dealing with mild fertility issues, or who are in certain situations:

  • If you are single or in a same-sex couple and don’t have any serious problems with your fertility. IUI can be done with donor sperm
  • If you don’t ovulate regularly
  • If you’re dealing with male infertility, but the problems are minor. For example, if there is a small problem with how well the sperm can move
  • If you are looking for a less invasive and lower-cost first step

Because the sperm needs to reach the egg on its own with IUI, it’s usually not effective for people with more complicated fertility problems. For example, if the sperm can’t swim properly or if there’s damaged Fallopian tubes.

Sometimes, IUI involves a stimulation phase. Only it will be less rigorous than IVF stimulation: lower doses of medication are used to ensure that no more than 1-2 eggs mature per cycle. If too many follicles start to develop, we may recommend cancelling the cycle. This is to prevent a pregnancy with triplets (or more), which comes with health risks.

Good to know: We may use stimulation medicine during IUI if you don’t ovulate regularly, or if we can see that your natural hormone levels aren’t optimal for supporting follicle development (follicles are sacs the eggs grow in).

Which is more successful, IVF or IUI?

Success rates are generally higher with IVF. Per the UK regulator, the HFEA, success rates for IUI tend to be about a third of that for IVF. For example, in one study of 300 women with fertility problems, 46% of those having IVF got pregnant compared to 33.3% of those who did IUI.

Why is this the case? It’s because IVF gives us a lot more control over the process. We can use medicines that allow us precise control over your hormone levels, which encourages your follicles to develop evenly. If more eggs mature at the same time, it usually means that we can collect more per cycle.

And if more eggs are collected and fertilised, we can then choose the best (the most likely to succeed) embryo of the bunch to transfer into the womb.

Whereas with IUI, we can select healthy sperm but we don’t have any control over what happens once it’s been inserted.

Good to know: The type of treatment you have isn’t the only thing that influences your odds of success. Your age, health and medical history, lifestyle, and more can all play a role.

Having both IUI and IVF

Some people will have both treatments over the course of their fertility journey. They might try IUI before doing IVF.

There’s no set number of IUI cycles that are recommended before you do IVF. It depends on your unique situation and your clinic will advise on what’s best for you personally.

I have unexplained fertility. Is IUI or IVF better for me?

It really depends on your circumstances. Your age, health and medical history, and the details of any other treatments you’ve tried, can all help determine which treatment is best.

The UK guidelines say that either IUI or IVF can be offered to people with unexplained fertility. So, it’s a decision for you and your doctor.

But broadly speaking, if you are older, other fertility treatments haven’t worked, and you have a health condition that could be affecting your fertility, IVF may be recommended. IUI might be suggested for younger people or those who don’t have fertility issues but are single or in a same-sex relationship.

IUI vs IVF: choosing your fertility treatment

Neither IUI or IVF is “better” than the other. They are different treatments, and what’s right for you depends on your situation. Your clinic will advise on which treatment can best support you.

When you work with ARGC, we will create a treatment plan tailored precisely to you. Before we prescribe you anything, we take the time to understand your situation: your fertility history, your health, your body’s natural rhythms and patterns. We call this your pre-treatment assessment. And we will only recommend IVF or IUI (or any other treatment) after it’s been completed, and we have a full picture of where you’re at right now.

This way, we can create a plan that’s best set up to support you. Your body is unique, and your fertility treatment should be, too.

Wondering whether ARGC is right for you? Our advisory calls are free, no-obligation, and led by someone who can answer your specific questions about treatment, costs, and what to expect. Book a call to get started.

Medically reviewed by
Kelda Gould avatar

Kelda Gould

Fertility Nurse • BN in Adult Nursing

Kelda Gould is a Registered Nurse specialising in fertility care. She holds a degree in Biochemistry and has over a decade of clinical experience spanning general nursing, outpatients, first response, and fertility care.

We’re here to support you at every stage of your journey.